Volume 21, Number 1
January 2022
DISCUSSION

Divine Commands Are Unnecessary for Moral Obligation

Volume 21, Number 1, January 2022, Pages 142–149
https://doi.org/10.26556/jesp.v21i1.1261
PDFPDF

Abstract

Divine command theory is experiencing something of a renaissance, inspired in large part by Robert Adams’s 1999 masterpiece Finite and Infinite Goods. I argue here that divine commands are not always necessary for actions to be morally obligatory. I make the case that the divine command theorist’s own commitments put pressure on her to concede the existence of some moral obligations that in no way depend on divine commands. Focusing on Robert Adams’s theistic framework for ethics, I argue that Adams’s views about good, evil, reasons, and the nature of moral obligation suggest that there can be moral obligations that exist independently of any divine commands. My argument proceeds through the development of an example in which there is a moral obligation that is not even partially grounded in a divine command. I focus primarily on Adams’s view because, many contemporary divine command theorists work in a broadly Adamsian framework, so the argument that I advance here poses a challenge for many contemporary versions of divine command theory.
Copyright © 2022 Erik J. Wielenberg
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International license.
|

Could Morality Have a Source?

Chris Heathwood

Unifying Moral and Epistemic Praiseworthiness

Leo Eisenbach

Being Wronged and Understanding Moral Wrongness

Daniel Vanello

When Enough Is Not Enough: Satisficing and Moral Efficiency

Konstantin Weber

Parents and Peers: A Kantian Moral Development

William Grant Ray

Soldiers and Moral Tragedy: Comments on Renzo

Christopher Kutz

Moral Disagreement and the Question Under Discussion

Stina Björkholm

Political Obligation and Political Recognition

Dan Khokhar

The Moral Harms of Homelessness

Bradley Hillier-Smith

It’s Only Natural! Moral Progress Through Denaturalization

Charlie Blunden

The Overweighted Integrity Problem: Conscience, Complicity, and Moral Standing

Kyle G. Fritz

Moral Worth in Gettier Cases

Neil Sinhababu

Portico