Volume 27, Number 1
March 2024
ARTICLE

Immoral Artistry? Reflections on Omar Little, Tony Soprano, and Value Interaction Debates

Volume 27, Number 1, March 2024, Pages 60–93
https://doi.org/10.26556/jesp.v27i1.2161
PDFPDF

Abstract

This paper uses detailed art criticism to ground a distinctive take on debates about the interaction of moral and aesthetic value. Immoralists claim that moral flaws can make artworks aesthetically better than they would otherwise be. I argue that whether or not immoralism is true, immoralists have not provided compelling characterizations of strategies that might constitute this kind of “immoral artistry.” The main exception is found in the work of A. W. Eaton. I critique Eaton’s perspective by way of sustained interpretive-philosophical discussion of The Wire and especially The Sopranos. The discussion has implications for value interaction debates, conceptualizations of the “rough hero” genre, theories of appropriate response to fictions, and more applied debates about the moral criticism of film and television.
Copyright © 2024 Sam Shpall
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International license.
|

Hypocrisy and Moral Authority

Jessica Isserow and Colin Klein

What Fictionalists Get Wrong About the Value of Winning

William J. Morgan

Fighting Unjust Wars: Political Authority, Tragic Choices, and the Value of Obedience

Massimo Renzo

Touching the Good: Special Relationships as Contact with Value

Adam Lovett and Stefan Riedener

Educational Justice and the Value of Excellence

Tammy Harel Ben Shahar

Murderers on the Ballot Paper: Bad Apples, Moral Compromise, and the Epistemic Value of Public Deliberation in Representative Democracies

Richard Beadon Williams

Value Capture

C. Thi Nguyen

The Value of Uptake

Anni Räty

Remaining True to Ourselves: Dementia, Value Change, and Enduring Interests

Andrew Franklin-Hall

The Value of a Life-Year and the Intuition of Universality

Marc Fleurbaey and Gregory Ponthiere

Normative Uncertainty Without Unjustified Value Comparison: A Response to Carr

Ron Aboodi

Basically Deserved Blame and Its Value

Michael McKenna

Portico