Volume 18, Number 1
July 2020
ARTICLE

The Demandingness of Virtue

Volume 18, Number 1, July 2020, Pages 1–22
https://doi.org/10.26556/jesp.v18i1.922
PDFPDF

Abstract

How demanding is the virtuous life? Can virtue exist alongside hints of vice? Is it possible to be virtuous within a vicious society? A line of thinking running through Diogenes and the Stoics is that even a hint of corruption is inimical to virtue, that participating in a vicious society makes it impossible for a person to be virtuous. One response to this difficulty is to claim that virtue is a threshold concept, that context sets a threshold for what is considered virtuous. On this way of thinking, what counts as virtuous in one society may be more demanding than what passes for virtuous in another. This response seems plausible when considering that virtue-theoretic terms like ‘honest’ are gradable adjectives. Many gradable adjectives, like ‘tall’ and ‘expensive’, have contextual thresholds that shift depending on the situation, and so is tenable that virtue-theoretic adjectives might function with contextual thresholds as well. A major difficulty for this response, however, is that virtue terms are absolute gradable adjectives, a variety of gradable adjectives that do not require a contextual threshold. Absolute gradable adjectives instead draw their truth conditions from their maximal degree, suggesting that Diogenes and the Stoics were correct to think that virtue is incompatible with even a small degree of vice.
Copyright © 2020 Robert Weston Siscoe
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International license.
|

A Theory of Collective Virtue

Matthew Baddorf and Noah McKay

Four Solutions to the Alleged Incompleteness of Virtue Ethics

Sean McAleer

Moral Vagueness and Epistemicism

John Hawthorne

The Importance of Roles in the Skill Analogy

Matt Dougherty

Humility and Ethical Development

Cathy Mason

Virtuous and Vicious Anger

Nicolas Bommarito

Character Traits, Social Psychology, and Impediments to Helping Behavior

Christian Miller

The Moral Virtue of Social Consciousness

Anna Brinkerhoff

Moral Demandingness and Modal Demandingness

Kyle York

Friendship as a Non-Relative Virtue

Rachel Friedman

Rethinking Demandingness: Why Satisficing Consequentialism and Scalar Consequentialism Are Not Less Demanding Than Maximizing Consequentialism

Spencer Case

What Knowledge Is Necessary for Virtue?

Olivia Bailey

Portico