ARTICLE
Slack Taking and Burden Dumping: Fair Cost Sharing in Duties to Rescue
Volume 23, Number 3, January 2023, Pages 343–364
PDFAbstract
Peter Singer argues that when some fail to do their part in alleviating suffering, the rest of us must take up their slack. In response, L. J. Cohen, Liam Murphy, and David Miller argue that such a requirement would be unfair. No one, they contend, should be required to contribute more than she would be required to under full compliance. I argue against Cohen, Murphy, and Miller that we are obligated to take up slack left by noncontributors, but agree that we are thereby treated unfairly. Drawing on the literatures on group causation and moral responsibility, I argue that noncontributors wrong those they fail to help and those who take up their slack. I refer to the latter kind of wrong as “burden dumping.” Furthermore, I argue that my account applies whether we conceive of rescue duties as discretionary or nondiscretionary. One might think that if my duties to rescue do not require me to contribute to any particular rescue effort, I do not dump burdens on anyone when I do nothing. In reply, I argue that when I have a nondiscretionary duty to contribute to a particular rescue effort, I unfairly dump burdens on those contributing to that effort when I fail to do my part. Similarly, when my duty to rescue is discretionary and I do nothing, I unfairly dump burdens on everyone whose rescue efforts I might have contributed to. Using this apparatus, we can account for the force of arguments such as Singer’s as well as the idea that those who dump burdens are blameworthy for treating other rescuers unfairly.
Copyright © 2023 Aaron Finley
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International license.
|
Rescue and Necessity: A Reply to Quong
Joel Joseph and Theron Pummer
The Fair Share Theory of Conventional Normativity
Adam Lovett
Rescue Cases, the Majority Rule, and the Greatest Number
Jonas Werner
Civil Disobedience and Animal Rescue: A Reply to Milligan
Daniel Weltman
The Best Available Parent and Duties of Justice
Jordan David Thomas Walters
Not Duties but Needs: Rethinking Refugeehood
Susanne Mantel
This paper has not yet been cited.
