Volume 25, Number 2
August 2023
DISCUSSION

Civil Disobedience and Animal Rescue: A Reply to Milligan

Volume 25, Number 2, August 2023, Pages 420–427
https://doi.org/10.26556/jesp.v25i2.2613
PDFPDF

Abstract

Tony Milligan argues that some forms of covert non-human animal rescue, wherein activists anonymously and illegally free non-human animals from confinement, should be understood as acts of civil disobedience. However, most traditional understandings of civil disobedience require that the civil disobedient act publicly rather than covertly. Thus Milligan’s proposal is that we revise our understanding of civil disobedience to allow for covert in addition to public disobedience. I argue we should not. Milligan cannot justify using paradigm cases to expand the scope of civil disobedience without justifying similar reasons to limit the scope, and he does nto give convincing reasons for discarding the communication requirement, according to which an action cannot count as civil disobedience unless it is communicative. The immediate conclusion is that animal rescue is not civil disobedience, while the broader conclusion is one about civil disobedience more broadly: an act must be public to count as civil disobedience.
Copyright © 2023 Daniel Weltman
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International license.
|

Democracy, Disobedience, and Accountability

Henry Krahn

How to Read a Riot

Ricky Mouser

Differentiating Disobedients

Chong-Ming Lim

Rescue and Necessity: A Reply to Quong

Joel Joseph and Theron Pummer

What Is (Fundamentally or Per Se) Wrong with Colonialism: A Reply to Agrawal and Buchanan

Daniel Weltman

Rescue Cases, the Majority Rule, and the Greatest Number

Jonas Werner

Not Living My Best Life: A Reply to Masny

Guy Fletcher

Privileged Citizens and the Right to Riot: A Reply to Pasternak

Thomas Carnes

The Case for Voting to Change the Outcomes Is Weaker Than It May Seem: A Reply to Zach Barnett

Amir Liron and David Enoch

Games Unlike Life: A Reply to Camp and Millgram

C. Thi Nguyen

Slack Taking and Burden Dumping: Fair Cost Sharing in Duties to Rescue

Aaron Finley

Other-Sacrificing Options: Reply to Lange

Romy Eskens

Portico