Volume 31, Number 1
February 2026
DISCUSSION

What Is (Fundamentally or Per Se) Wrong with Colonialism: A Reply to Agrawal and Buchanan

Volume 31, Number 1, February 2026, Pages 139–146
https://doi.org/10.26556/jesp.v31i1.4433
PDFPDF

Abstract

Ritwik Agrawal and Allen Buchanan argue that the fundamental wrong of colonialism is a denial of autonomy to those who are colonized. They claim that earlier discussions of colonialism, including those by Lea Ypi, Anna Stilz, and Massimo Renzo, mischaracterize the fundamental wrong of colonialism as something else. I argue that Agrawal and Buchanan incorrectly charge Ypi, Stilz, Renzo, and others with looking for the fundamental wrong of colonialism. The goal of these thinkers is instead to articulate the per se wrong of colonialism, which is a separate question. I also argue that Agrawal and Buchanan do not identify the fundamental wrong of colonialism, because paradigmatic cases of wrongful colonialism fail to instantiate the wrong that Agrawal and Buchanan label fundamental.
Copyright © 2026 Daniel Weltman
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International license.
|

The Fair Share Theory of Conventional Normativity

Adam Lovett

Value Capture

C. Thi Nguyen

Allies Against Oppression: Intersectional Feminism, Critical Race Theory, and Rawlsian Liberalism

Marcus Arvan

Are Savior Siblings a Special Case in Procreative Ethics?

Caleb Althorpe and Elizabeth Finneron-Burns

Freedom, Desire, and Necessity: Autonomous Activity as Activity for Its Own Sake

Pascal L. Mowla Brixel

The Trouble with Formal Views of Autonomy

Jonathan Knutzen

Prioritarianism: A (Pluralist) Defence

Shai Agmon and Matt Hitchens

Colburn on Anti-Perfectionism and Autonomy

Thomas Porter

The Enforcement Approach to Coercion

Scott A. Anderson

First Force

William A. Edmundson

In Defense of Discretionary Association Theories of Political Legitimacy: Reply to Buchanan

Marcus Arvan

What Fictionalists Get Wrong About the Value of Winning

William J. Morgan

Portico