Volume 30, Number 5
September 2025
SYMPOSIUM

The Weight of Authority in War: Comments on Renzo

Volume 30, Number 5, September 2025, Pages 776–794
https://doi.org/10.26556/jesp.v30i5.4143
PDFPDF

Abstract

In Massimo Renzo’s paper “Political Authority and Unjust War,” he defends an argument from authority to the effect that in principle, a soldier may be obligated and so permitted to follow orders even if they are understood to order killing of enemy soldiers who ought not to be killed. I propose some clarifications in the use of the ideas of duty and wrong, before turning to the conflict between such arguments from authority and some deep intuitions about the moral gravity of killing. A more restrictive view has come to be influential partly on that basis, but I argue in defense of Renzo that the restrictive view also conflicts with deep intuitions, including about the permissibility of duly commanded military killing in national defense against conquest or annexation. I argue that the national defense example puts arguments from authority in a sufficiently promising light that its tension with intuitions about killing is far from dispositive against it.
Copyright © 2025 David Estlund
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International license.
|

Soldiers and Moral Tragedy: Comments on Renzo

Christopher Kutz

Liberty, Equality, Authority

David Owens

Against Deference to Authority

Travis Quigley

Must States Do It Themselves? A Rights-Based Theory of Delegating State Coercion

Vincent Chiao

Who Do You Speak For? And How? Online Abuse as Collective Subordinating Speech Acts

Michael Randall Barnes

The Limits of Instrumental Proceduralism

Jake Monaghan

Positive Rights: Two-Person Cases

David Alm

Disagreement, Unilateral Judgment, and Kant’s Argument for Rule by Law

Daniel Koltonski

Risking Civilian Lives to Avoid Harm to Cultural Heritage?

William Bülow

The Enforcement Approach to Coercion

Scott A. Anderson

Well-Being and Virtue

Daniel M. Haybron

First Force

William A. Edmundson

Portico