Volume 31, Number 2
March 2026
DISCUSSION

A Defense of the Cautionary Approach to Supererogation

and
Volume 31, Number 2, March 2026, Pages 296–303
https://doi.org/10.26556/jesp.v31i2.4438
PDFPDF
MP3

Abstract

How can moral theory make room for the existence of acts that are beyond the call of duty? This issue has become known as the problem of supererogation, and philosophers have provided various accounts of how to solve it. We have provided a recent answer to this question that draws on the work of the eleventh-century Persian philosopher Abū Alī Miskawayh and holds that we can make sense of supererogatory actions by appealing to a form of moral caution. In a recent response to this article, Alireza Kazemi argues that this cautionary account cannot explain the existence of supererogatory acts. In this short reply, we defend the cautionary account against Kazemi’s criticisms. We start by briefly outlining our cautionary account and Kazemi’s criticisms before providing our own arguments as to why the cautionary account should not be rejected.
Copyright © 2026 Alfred Archer and Seyyed Mohsen Eslami
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International license.
|

Forcing Cohen to Abandon Forced Supererogation

Alfred Archer

In Defense of the Primacy of the Virtues

Jason Kawall

When Enough Is Not Enough: Satisficing and Moral Efficiency

Konstantin Weber

Gratitude for What We Are Owed

Aaron Eli Segal

Moral Demandingness and Modal Demandingness

Kyle York

Friendship as a Non-Relative Virtue

Rachel Friedman

Rethinking Demandingness: Why Satisficing Consequentialism and Scalar Consequentialism Are Not Less Demanding Than Maximizing Consequentialism

Spencer Case

What About Ought? Response to Practical Intelligence and the Virtues

Liezl van Zyl

What Knowledge Is Necessary for Virtue?

Olivia Bailey

Elicitory Structural Power and Agential Power: An Outline and Defense

Arash Abizadeh

In Defense of the Trolley Method

Ian Stoner and Jason Swartwood

Enclaves for the Excluded: A Pessimistic Defense

Jamie Draper

Portico