Volume 8, Number 1
August 2014
ARTICLE

Against Institutional Luck Egalitarianism

Volume 8, Number 1, August 2014, Pages 1–20
https://doi.org/10.26556/jesp.v8i1.78
PDFPDF

Abstract

Kok-Chor Tan has recently defended a novel theory of egalitarian distributive justice, institutional luck egalitarianism (ile). On this theory, it is unjust for institutions to favor some individuals over others based on matters of luck. Tan takes his theory to preserve the intuitive appeal of luck egalitarianism while avoiding what he regards as absurd implications that face other versions of luck egalitarianism. Despite the centrality of the concept of institutional influence to his theory, Tan never spells out precisely what it means for an inequality to be produced by an institution. In this paper, I consider different conceptions of institutional influence that ile might employ. It appears that however this concept is construed, ile has serious problems. On some conceptions, the luck egalitarian character of the theory is undermined. On others, the theory gives rise to precisely the sorts of absurd implications facing other versions of luck egalitarianism that Tan takes his theory to avoid.
Copyright © 2014 Rekha Nath
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International license.
|

Rights Infringement, Compensation, and Luck Egalitarianism

Jesse Spafford

Against Vote Markets: A Reply to Freiman

Alfred Archer and Alan T. Wilson

Liberty, Equality, Authority

David Owens

Fairness, Costs, and Procreative Justice

Gideon Elford

Children, Partiality, and Equality

David O'Brien

Freedom to Roam

Matthias Brinkmann

Reply to Critics of The Constitution of Equality

Thomas Christiano

Judicial Review and Democratic Authority: Absolute vs. Balancing Conceptions

Corey Brettschneider

The Limits of Democratic Authority

C. L. Ten

Egalitarian Justice and Innocent Choice

Nir Eyal

Essentially Comparative Concepts

Jonathan Dancy

Against the Right to Work, For the Right to Contribute

Jordan Desmond

Portico