Volume 30, Number 1
March 2025
ARTICLE

Nonideal Theory as Ideology

Volume 30, Number 1, March 2025, Pages 74–97
https://doi.org/10.26556/jesp.v30i1.4305
PDFPDF
MP3

Abstract

In the wake of the nonideal theory turn in political philosophy, few have paused to ask: Is nonideal theory a form of ideology? And perhaps even fewer have paused to ask: Is the debate between ideal/nonideal theorists itself a form of ideology? To the first question, I argue that nonideal theory is ideological in virtue of the fact that it rules out more utopian ways of theorizing by methodological fiat, and in so doing, risks entrenching an unjust status quo. To the second question, I argue that the debate between ideal/nonideal theorists is itself a form of ideology, one which serves to reinforce the status quo by convincing political philosophers/theorists that the most pressing problems are problems about what we should think about what we are doing. But this is false. An upshot of my argument is that we ought to abandon the ideal/nonideal theory debate and address the pressing problems of political philosophy head-on in pluralist fashion, oscillating back and forth between these two modes of theorizing without a decision procedure to tell us when we should take up one perspective or the other.
Copyright © 2025 Jordan David Thomas Walters
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International license.
|

Social Reform in a Complex World

Jacob Barrett

Allies Against Oppression: Intersectional Feminism, Critical Race Theory, and Rawlsian Liberalism

Marcus Arvan

Betrayed Expectations: Misdirected Anger and the Preservation of Ideology

Barrett Emerick and Audrey Yap

Nonideal Justice, Fairness, and Affirmative Action

Matthew Adams

Must States Do It Themselves? A Rights-Based Theory of Delegating State Coercion

Vincent Chiao

The Fair Share Theory of Conventional Normativity

Adam Lovett

Challenges for the Inability Theory of Disability

Stephanie Elsen

A Fiduciary Theory of Property

Rutger Claassen

A Theory of Collective Virtue

Matthew Baddorf and Noah McKay

Nonnaturalism, the Supervenience Challenge, Higher-Order Properties, and Trope Theory

Jussi Suikkanen

Combatants, Masculinity, and Just War Theory

Graham Parsons

Prudential Parity Objections to the Moral Error Theory

François Jaquet

Portico