Volume 30, Number 2
April 2025
ARTICLE

A Fiduciary Theory of Property

Volume 30, Number 2, April 2025, Pages 205–240
https://doi.org/10.26556/jesp.v30i2.4064
PDFPDF
MP3

Abstract

Ownership rights give substantial power to owners to affect the lives of nonowners. Critics of ownership’s power have compared it to the power of political rulers. Drawing on this analogy, this paper proposes to reconceptualize property as a fiduciary power. In a fiduciary relation, a fiduciary is empowered to make decisions over a beneficiary, for the interest of that beneficiary. The power is held in trust. Political rulers can be seen as a fiduciary for their subjects. Can ownership also be seen as a fiduciary relation? Mainstream libertarian and egalitarian property theories reject this analogy, adhere to an absolutist notion of property, and hold that problematic forms of ownership power should be restricted, if at all, by state regulation. Fiduciary (or “stewardship”) property theories have so far been confined to religious and environmentalist property theories. This paper proposes an egalitarian, secular fiduciary property theory. First, it builds on Larissa Katz’s theory of ownership as an office: a legally created power that makes owners into fiduciaries for the legal system. Second, it argues that owners become fiduciaries for specific nonowners when they risk exploiting them. Exploitation happens when nonowners are unfairly taken advantage of; it requires the acceptance of a specific theory of justice. By avoiding exploitation, owners contribute to realizing a just society. Third, the paper argues that to implement fiduciary duties in legal practice, both court enforcement and democratization of ownership structures are possible legal pathways. Fourth, it compares this proposal to other duty-oriented property theories and defends it against objections.
Copyright © 2025 Rutger Claassen
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International license.
|

Liberty, Equality, Authority

David Owens

Famine, Affluence, and Aquinas

Marshall Bierson and Tucker Sigourney

Must States Do It Themselves? A Rights-Based Theory of Delegating State Coercion

Vincent Chiao

The Fair Share Theory of Conventional Normativity

Adam Lovett

Challenges for the Inability Theory of Disability

Stephanie Elsen

Nonideal Theory as Ideology

Jordan David Thomas Walters

A Theory of Collective Virtue

Matthew Baddorf and Noah McKay

Nonnaturalism, the Supervenience Challenge, Higher-Order Properties, and Trope Theory

Jussi Suikkanen

Combatants, Masculinity, and Just War Theory

Graham Parsons

Allies Against Oppression: Intersectional Feminism, Critical Race Theory, and Rawlsian Liberalism

Marcus Arvan

Prudential Parity Objections to the Moral Error Theory

François Jaquet

Error Theory, Unbelievability, and the Normative Objection

Daniele Bruno

Portico