Is Intellectual Humility Compatible with Political Conviction?

Michael Hannon; Ian James Kidd

doi:https://doi.org/10.26556/jesp.v27i2.2856

Volume 27, Number 2
April 2024

ARTICLE

Is Intellectual Humility Compatible with Political Conviction?

and

Volume 27, Number 2, April 2024, Pages 211–233

https://doi.org/10.26556/jesp.v27i2.2856

PDF

Abstract

Intellectual humility is often proposed, these days, as an antidote to the profound lack of respect, tolerance, and openness to other views in contemporary politics. Moreover, deficiencies of intellectual humility are clearly at work in now-familiar displays, in political discourse, of arrogance, dogmatism and related phenomena, like polarization. Although we agree that there are roles for intellectual humility, we identify two problems. First, previous research on the relationship between intellectual humility and political conviction has ignored empirical and theoretical work indicating that humility does often result in apathy or lack of political conviction. Second, there are different forms or kinds of intellectual humility which can relate to political conviction in many ways. We end the paper by describing a kind of political quietism, which includes quite different accounts of the nature of intellectual humility.

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International license.

|

Humility and Ethical Development

Cathy Mason

Differentiating Disobedients

Chong-Ming Lim

Grounding Human Rights in Political Conceptions

Bosko Tripkovic

Political Forgetting

Alexander Bryan

The Practice Account of Political Authority

Fabian Wendt

Making Sense of Political Normativity

Mike Gadomski

Fighting Unjust Wars: Political Authority, Tragic Choices, and the Value of Obedience

Massimo Renzo

Political Obligation and Political Recognition

Dan Khokhar

Weakness of Political Will

Camila Hernandez Flowerman

Political Disagreement and Minimal Epistocracy

Adam F. Gibbons

The Human Right to Political Participation

Fabienne Peter

Is a Feminist Political Liberalism Possible?

Christie Hartley and Lori Watson