Volume 17, Number 2
April 2020
DISCUSSION

Error Theory, Unbelievability, and the Normative Objection

Volume 17, Number 2, April 2020, Pages 219–227
https://doi.org/10.26556/jesp.v17i2.908
PDFPDF

Abstract

One of the most formidable challenges to the Error Theory is the Normative Objection, according to which the Error Theory ought to be rejected because of its deeply implausible first-order normative implications. Recently, Bart Streumer has offered a novel and powerful defense of the Error Theory against this objection. Streumer argues that the Error Theory’s plausibility deficit when viewed against the background of our normative beliefs does not show the theory’s falsity. Rather, it can be explained by the fact that this theory, though true, cannot be believed. In this paper, I argue that Streumer’s defense does not succeed. I show that, even if we grant Streumer that we cannot believe the Error Theory, we can still formulate what I call the Undermining Normative Objection, an argument that proceeds only from believable premises to a believable conclusion and shows that the arguments supporting the Error Theory cannot all be sound.
Copyright © 2020 Daniele Bruno
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International license.
|

Moral Error Theory and the Argument from Epistemic Reasons

Rach Cosker-Rowland

Are Moral Error Theorists Intellectually Vicious?

Stephen Ingram

Non-Analytical Naturalism and the Nature of Normative Thought: A Reply to Parfit

Nicholas Laskowski

The Goal Problem in the “Now What” Problem

Xinkan Zhao

Inescapability and Normativity

Matthew Silverstein

The Normative Pluriverse

Matti Eklund

Constitutivism Without Normative Thresholds

Kathryn Lindeman

Normative Pluralism Worthy of the Name Is False

Spencer Case

The Normative Significance of Self

Dale Dorsey

Against Scanlon’s Theory of the Strength of Practical Reasons

Eric Sampson

A Danger of Definition: Polar Predicates in Moral Theory

Mark Alfano

Cudworth and Normative Explanations

Mark Schroeder

Portico