Volume 5, Number 2
October 2011
ARTICLE

Saving Lives and Respecting Persons

and
Volume 5, Number 2, October 2011, Pages 1–21
https://doi.org/10.26556/jesp.v5i2.51
PDFPDF

Abstract

In the distribution of resources, persons must be respected, or so many philosophers contend. Unfortunately, they often leave it unclear why a certain allocation would respect persons, while another would not. In this paper, we explore what it means to respect persons in the distribution of scarce, life-saving resources. We begin by presenting two kinds of cases. In different age cases, we have a drug that we must use either to save a young person who would live for many more years or an old person who would only live for a few. In different numbers cases, we must save either one person or many persons from certain death. We argue that two familiar accounts of respect for persons―an equal worth account, suggested by Jeff McMahan, and a Kantian account, inspired by the Formula of Humanity―have implausible implications in such cases. We develop a new, “three-tiered” account: one that, we claim, generates results in such cases that accord better with many people’s considered judgments than those produced by its rivals.
Copyright © 2011 Greg Bognar and Samuel J. Kerstein
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International license.
|

Should Desert Replace Equality? Replies to Kagan

Michael Weber

Saving People and Flipping Coins

Ben Bradley

Kant and the Balance of Moral Forces

Santiago Sanchez Borboa

Risk and the Unfairness of Some Being Better Off at the Expense of Others

Thomas Rowe

Egalitarian Justice and Innocent Choice

Nir Eyal

Chance, Epistemic Probability and Saving Lives: Reply to Bradley

Michael J. Almeida

What Makes Nepotism Wrong?

Pascal L. Mowla Mowla

Three Kinds of Prioritarianism

Carlos Soto

What Relational Egalitarians Should (Not) Believe

Andreas Bengtson and Lauritz Aastrup Munch

Adding Insult to Injury: Is Censorship Insulting?

Sebastien Bishop

How to Read a Riot

Ricky Mouser

Agnosticism and Pluralism About Justice

Adam Gjesdal

Portico