Volume 26, Number 1
November 2023
ARTICLE

Agnosticism and Pluralism About Justice

Volume 26, Number 1, November 2023, Pages 27–48
https://doi.org/10.26556/jesp.v26i1.1837
PDFPDF

Abstract

Political liberalism views a public policy as justified when reasonable citizens subject to it have sufficient reasons to endorse it. But this endorsement condition does not specify how reasonable citizens in democracies are to exercise their equal say in deciding which policies to support prior to enactment. Citizens may regard many policy options as reasonable but only one as truly just. The dominant view among political liberals, which I call agnosticism, takes no stand on how citizens ought to rank these reasonable alternatives to determine which to support. Agnostics see all criteria for comparing reasonable policies as on a par, whether they be theories of justice or coin flips. I show how Quong’s analysis of reasonableness leads to agnosticism. I then develop the pluralist alternative, which holds that citizens should support the reasonable policy they regard as most just. What I call pluralism sees multiple conceptions of justice as correct, or “most reasonable.” I show that pluralism offers a compelling alternative to agnosticism in that it can both make sense of an individual citizen’s duty to support what they regard as just policy and respect the fact that citizens reasonably disagree about what the most just policy is.
Copyright © 2023 Adam Gjesdal
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International license.
|

Making Sense of Political Normativity

Mike Gadomski

The Purpose and Limits of Electoral Accountability

Finlay Malcolm

In or Out? Benevolent Absolutisms in The Law of Peoples

Robert Huseby

Reciprocity and Liberal Legitimacy: Critical Comment on May

Blain Neufeld

Beyond a Strictly Political Liberalism? Critical Response to Abbey

Akira Inoue

Egalitarian Justice and Innocent Choice

Nir Eyal

News Journalism and the Principles of Objectivity

Dhananjay Jagannathan and Clara Ence Morse

Politics and Foreign Donations

Andreas Bengtson and Dick Timmer

Political Forgetting

Alexander Bryan

War, Legitimacy, and Democracy: Comments on Renzo

Thomas Christiano

Democracy, Disobedience, and Accountability

Henry Krahn

There Is No Institutional Duty to Vote

Jason Brennan and Christopher Freiman

Portico