Volume 8, Number 1
August 2014
DISCUSSION

How Not to Defend Moral Blame

Volume 8, Number 1, August 2014, Pages 1–8
https://doi.org/10.26556/jesp.v8i1.159
PDFPDF

Abstract

At first sight, moral blame is an unpleasant thing. No one likes being blamed and few people like experiencing the negative emotions associated with blaming others. Therefore, some suggest a radical reform of our everyday moral life: We should replace our tendency to blame wrongdoers with a tendency to criticize them in a less harmful and more productive way. The blameless fight for the good by Martin Luther King Jr. and Mahatma Gandhi may exemplify this alternative. Many philosophers, however, think that such a reform would be bad. In this discussion note, I will focus on R. Jay Wallace’s claim that our tendency to blame wrongdoers stands in relation to some important good such that we would necessarily lose this good if we stopped blaming each other. He argues that blaming wrongdoers expresses one’s commitment to morality in a special way and that no other response could serve this function. I will show that there are forms of moral sadness in our psychological repertoire that differ from blame but have the same expressive dimension that blame is supposed to have. Thus, I will suggest that the question of whether we should try to get rid of our tendency to blame is still open.
Copyright © 2014 Andreas Leonhard Menges
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International license.
|

Personal Reactive Attitudes and Partial Responses to Others: A Partiality-Based Approach to Strawson’s Reactive Attitudes

Rosalind Chaplin

The Overweighted Integrity Problem: Conscience, Complicity, and Moral Standing

Kyle G. Fritz

Sulking into Sex: Blame, Coercion, and Consent

Sumeet Patwardhan

Dismissing Blame

Justin Snedegar

Addressed Blame and Hostility

Benjamin De Mesel

The Comparative Nonarbitrariness Norm of Blame

Daniel Telech and Hannah Tierney

Basically Deserved Blame and Its Value

Michael McKenna

Oppression, Forgiveness, and Ceasing to Blame

Luke Brunning and Per-Erik Milam

Introducing Discord

Mark Schroeder

Enclaves for the Excluded: A Pessimistic Defense

Jamie Draper

Crime, Public Health, and Inhumane Objectivity

Nadine Elzein

Letting Animals Off the Hook

Nicolas Delon

Portico