Volume 9, Number 1
May 2015
ARTICLE

How to Solve Prichard’s Dilemma: A Complex Contractualist Account of Moral Motivation

Volume 9, Number 1, May 2015, Pages 1–20
https://doi.org/10.26556/jesp.v9i1.86
PDFPDF

Abstract

T. M. Scanlon’s contractualist account of morality is articulated alongside and built upon groundbreaking work on moral motivation. According to Scanlon, the central challenge of providing an account of moral motivation is navigating “Prichard’s Dilemma,” which requires that an account be both (a) helpfully explanatory and (b) morally relevant. Scanlon’s own solution is that one has a reason to act rightly because doing so is an aspect of living with others on terms they could accept. There is much to like about this account, and so, in this paper, I begin with many of Scanlon’s assumptions. I then argue that Scanlon’s own account of moral motivation fails to navigate Prichard’s Dilemma, as does another solution that I derive from his broader view. I then close by suggesting that an account of moral motivation must be “complex,” involving different reasons to satisfy the competing desiderata of Prichard’s Dilemma.
Copyright © 2015 Travis N. Rieder
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International license.
|

Is There Value in Keeping a Promise? A Response to Joseph Raz

Crescente Molina

Ends to Means

Matthew S. Bedke

Against Scanlon’s Theory of the Strength of Practical Reasons

Eric Sampson

An Actual-Sequence Theory of Promotion

D. Justin Coates

Hume’s Internalism Reconsidered

Dale Dorsey

Instrumental Rationality: A Reprise

Joseph Raz

The Myth of Instrumental Rationality

Joseph Raz

Naturalizing Moral Naturalism

Jessica Isserow

Moral Error Theory and the Argument from Epistemic Reasons

Rach Cosker-Rowland

Grounding Human Rights in Political Conceptions

Bosko Tripkovic

Why Contractualism Cannot Accept Equal Treatment for Equal Statistical Loss

Jay Zemeska

Leaving Principle Contractualism Behind? A Response to Salomon

Valentin Salein

Portico