Volume 14, Number 1
October 2018
ARTICLE

Immigrant Selection, Health Requirements, and Disability Discrimination

Volume 14, Number 1, October 2018, Pages 44–82
https://doi.org/10.26556/jesp.v14i1.370
PDFPDF

Abstract

Australia, Canada, and New Zealand currently apply health requirements to prospective immigrants, denying residency to those with health conditions that are likely to impose an “excessive demand” on their publicly funded health and social service programs. In this paper, I investigate the charge that such policies are wrongfully discriminatory against persons with disabilities. I first provide a freedom-based account of the wrongness of discrimination according to which discrimination is wrong when and because it involves disadvantaging people in the exercise of their freedom on the basis of morally arbitrary features of their identity. Discrimination is permissible, I suggest, when it is necessary to advance a valuable exercise of the discriminating agent’s freedom. I then apply this account to the case of social cost health requirements. Against critics of these requirements, I argue that it is sometimes permissible for states to discriminate against prospective immigrants with disabilities. States may do so, I suggest, when such discriminatory treatment is necessary to prevent an increase in rates of mortality and/or morbidity among citizens. Alongside critics of social cost health requirements however, I argue that existing policies are likely a form of wrongful discrimination insofar as they are too broad to satisfy this standard.
Copyright © 2018 Douglas MacKay
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International license.
|

Challenges for the Inability Theory of Disability

Stephanie Elsen

Enclaves for the Excluded: A Pessimistic Defense

Jamie Draper

Separating the Wrong of Settlement from the Right to Exclude: Territory and Sociocultural Stability

Daniel Guillery

Territorial Exclusion: An Argument Against Closed Borders

Daniel Weltman

Does Deportation Infringe Rights?

Kaila Draper

Doing and Allowing Harm to Refugees

Bradley Hillier-Smith

The Right to Exclude Immigrants Does Not Imply the Right to Exlude Newcomers by Birth

Thomas Carnes

Is Liberalism Committed to Its Own Demise?

Hrishikesh Joshi

Immigration Policy and Identification Across Borders

Matthew Lindauer

Liberalism or Immigration Restrictions, But Not Both

Christopher Freiman and Javier Hidalgo

Distributing Collective Obligation

Sean Aas

Immigration Restrictions and the Right to Avoid Unwanted Obligations

Javier Hidalgo

Portico