Volume 14, Number 1
October 2018
ARTICLE

The Right to Exclude Immigrants Does Not Imply the Right to Exlude Newcomers by Birth

Volume 14, Number 1, October 2018, Pages 28–43
https://doi.org/10.26556/jesp.v14i1.359
PDFPDF

Abstract

A recent challenge to statist arguments defending the right of states to exclude prospective immigrants maintains that such statist arguments prove too much. Specifically, the challenge argues that statist arguments, insofar as they are correct, entail that states may permissibily exclude current members’ newcomers by birth, which seems to violate a widely held intuition that members’ newcomers by birth ought automatically to be granted membership rights. The basic claim is that statist arguments cannot account for the differntial treatment between prospective immigrants and newcomers by birth. Call this the newcomer-by-birth objection. This article rejects the newcomer-by-birth rejection. It begins by sketching the precise extent to which the objection applies to statist arguments. It then examines the case of newcomers by birth and argues for a principled basis for treating them differentially from prospective immigrants such that a right to exclude prospective immigrants need not entail a right to exclude newcomers by birth. But this distinction holds only in most cases, not all, and therefore the newcomer-by-birth objection is not entirely defeated. With respect to the cases in which the objection does hold, it is argued that such cases are morally akin to international adoption, and thus morally benign. All considered, statist arguments easily survive the newcomer-by-birth objection.
Copyright © 2018 Thomas Carnes
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International license.
|

Territorial Exclusion: An Argument Against Closed Borders

Daniel Weltman

Separating the Wrong of Settlement from the Right to Exclude: Territory and Sociocultural Stability

Daniel Guillery

Does Deportation Infringe Rights?

Kaila Draper

Immigration Restrictions and the Right to Avoid Unwanted Obligations

Javier Hidalgo

Enclaves for the Excluded: A Pessimistic Defense

Jamie Draper

Doing and Allowing Harm to Refugees

Bradley Hillier-Smith

Immigrant Selection, Health Requirements, and Disability Discrimination

Douglas MacKay

Is Liberalism Committed to Its Own Demise?

Hrishikesh Joshi

Immigration Policy and Identification Across Borders

Matthew Lindauer

Liberalism or Immigration Restrictions, But Not Both

Christopher Freiman and Javier Hidalgo

Institutional Conservatism and the Right to Exclude

Hallvard Sandven

Against the Right to Work, For the Right to Contribute

Jordan Desmond

Portico