Volume 23, Number 1
October 2022
ARTICLE

Expecting Equality: How Prenatal Screening Policy Harms People with Disabilities

Volume 23, Number 1, October 2022, Pages 32–58
https://doi.org/10.26556/jesp.v23i1.1591
PDFPDF

Abstract

The “expressivist objection” argues that prenatal screening leading to termination of embryos or fetuses with disabilities sends a harmful message to people with disabilities, such as the message that their lives are not worth living. I first argue that whether it sends such a message depends on how a reasonable person would see the motives behind the screening. I then argue that a reasonable person would see a harmful message, not when individuals terminate embryos, and not for severe disabilities, but when the state allows the screening and termination of embryos with less severe conditions, such as Down syndrome. This sends the message that it is permissible not to pay a higher cost to support people with disabilities, when there is an abled alternative. This attitude is harmful to the welfare, rights and self-worth of people with disabilities because it reinforces the refusal to provide them with equal opportunity. The state therefore has a strong pro tanto reason to ban prenatal screening for less severe disabilities.
Copyright © 2022 Athmeya Jayaram
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International license.
|

Speechlessness and Linguistic Reciprocity in Arendt

Magnus Ferguson

Challenges for the Inability Theory of Disability

Stephanie Elsen

What Is the Bad-Difference View of Disability?

Thomas Crawley

Disability as Inability

Alex Gregory

Well-Being, Opportunity, and Selecting for Disability

S. Andrew Schroeder

Is It Bad to Be Disabled? Adjudicating Between the Mere-Difference and the Bad-Difference Views of Disability

Vuko Andrić and Joachim Wündisch

Liberty, Equality, Authority

David Owens

Reparations, Relational Equality, and Causation

Felix Lambrecht

Supersession-Proof Reparations: Harms, Wrongs, and Historical Injustice

Felix Lambrecht

The Moral Harms of Homelessness

Bradley Hillier-Smith

The Need for Merely Possible People

Johan E. Gustafsson

The Problem of Basic Equality: A Constructive Critique

Nikolas Kirby

Portico