Volume 2, Number 2
February 2008
ARTICLE

“Simply In Virtue of Being Human”: The Whos and Whys of Human Rights

Volume 2, Number 2, February 2008, Pages 1–23
https://doi.org/10.26556/jesp.v2i2.23
PDFPDF

Abstract

In this paper I raise some questions about the familiar claim, recently reiterated by James Griffin, that human rights are rights that humans have “simply in virtue of being human.” I ask, in particular, how we are to read the words ‘simply in virtue of’. Are we speaking of who has the rights (A has them if and only if he or she is human) or why they have the rights (A has them because and only because he or she is human)? Griffin brings the two readings together, as two sides of the same coin. He offers a (more or less) universalistic case for (more or less) universalistic rights. I try to show how the two readings can be driven apart, how the universality of human rights need not be undermined merely by there being no adequate universalistic case for them. On the strength of this discussion I suggest an inversion of the relationship that is often thought to hold between human rights and human dignity. In a way our rights give us our dignity, not vice versa. And in a way this helps to make the case for the universality of human rights.
Copyright © 2008 John Gardner
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International license.
|

Reply to Critics of The Constitution of Equality

Thomas Christiano

Judicial Review and Democratic Authority: Absolute vs. Balancing Conceptions

Corey Brettschneider

Is a Feminist Political Liberalism Possible?

Christie Hartley and Lori Watson

Rights Infringement, Compensation, and Luck Egalitarianism

Jesse Spafford

In Defense of Claim Rights

Michael Da Silva

On the Normative Connection Between Paternalism and Rights

Stephanie Sheintul

Rights, Roles, and Interests

Robert Mullins

Risk and the Unfairness of Some Being Better Off at the Expense of Others

Thomas Rowe

Against the Being For Account of Normative Certitude

Krister Bykvist and Jonas Olson

Unifying Moral and Epistemic Praiseworthiness

Leo Eisenbach

The Fair Share Theory of Conventional Normativity

Adam Lovett

Letting Animals Off the Hook

Nicolas Delon

Portico