Volume 24, Number 3
April 2023
ARTICLE

Institutional Conservatism and the Right to Exclude

Volume 24, Number 3, April 2023, Pages 409–433
https://doi.org/10.26556/jesp.v24i3.1597
PDFPDF

Abstract

This article offers a critical discussion of “institutional conservatism” in political philosophy on migration. These are normative theories of exclusion grounded in minimal descriptive accounts of the state. It argues that this methodological strategy, which has been deployed most prominently by Michael Blake and Sarah Song, demands serious attention because it enables the avoidance of a problem of applicability that is pervasive across different theories of the right to exclude. The article then shows that, despite its initial appeal, institutionally conservative theories face a different problem. Their state-based methodology renders them structurally incapable of generating a convincing account of the legitimacy of border control, as distinct from an account of justice in immigration policy. Building on this argument, the article provides further support for the claim that the ethics of migration should turn towards an analysis of the state system.
Copyright © 2023 Hallvard Sandven
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International license.
|

Must States Do It Themselves? A Rights-Based Theory of Delegating State Coercion

Vincent Chiao

Fake News and Democracy

Merten Reglitz

The Limits of Instrumental Proceduralism

Jake Monaghan

Not Duties but Needs: Rethinking Refugeehood

Susanne Mantel

In Defense of Discretionary Association Theories of Political Legitimacy: Reply to Buchanan

Marcus Arvan

Separating the Wrong of Settlement from the Right to Exclude: Territory and Sociocultural Stability

Daniel Guillery

The Right to Exclude Immigrants Does Not Imply the Right to Exlude Newcomers by Birth

Thomas Carnes

Against the Right to Work, For the Right to Contribute

Jordan Desmond

There Is No Institutional Duty to Vote

Jason Brennan and Christopher Freiman

Doxastic Partiality and the Puzzle of Enticing Right Action

Max Lewis

Probability, Normalcy, and the Right Against Risk Imposition

Martin Smith

The Right to Mental Autonomy: Its Nature and Scope

William Ratoff

Portico