Volume 28, Number 1
July 2024
ARTICLE

The Challenge for Coronavirus Vaccine Testing

Volume 28, Number 1, July 2024, Pages 30–52
https://doi.org/10.26556/jesp.v28i1.2572
PDFPDF

Abstract

Can we permissibly accelerate vaccine testing even if this increases risk to study participants? During the covid-19 pandemic, researchers, policymakers, and bioethicists debated ways in which vaccine development could be expedited. One suggestion were human challenge trials which only started after safe and efficacious vaccine had already been developed. Was this hesitation justified? Can challenge trials play a role in future pandemics? I defend both a version of challenge trials—a low-dosage challenge trial—and a faster option for post-challenge trial safety testing. My argument draws on a new framework for risks in biomedical research. The new framework, embedded in a broader approach to the ethics of risk, can justify seemingly risky research while remaining strongly protective of the rights and interests of research participants. My argument furthermore draws on considerations about the connection between the risks to study participants, the benefits to nonparticipants, and the number of participants involved.
Copyright © 2024 Bastian Steuwer
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International license.
|

Contractualism and Compensation for Risk Impositions

Richard Endörfer

Why Contractualism Cannot Accept Equal Treatment for Equal Statistical Loss

Jay Zemeska

Three Kinds of Prioritarianism

Carlos Soto

Probability, Normalcy, and the Right Against Risk Imposition

Martin Smith

Maxim and Principle Contractualism

Aaron Salomon

The Red Mist

Maxime Lepoutre

Agency, Stability, and Permeability in “Games”

Elisabeth Camp

How We Can Make Sense of Control-Based Intuitions for Limited Access Conceptions of the Right to Privacy

Björn Lundgren

Nonideal Justice, Fairness, and Affirmative Action

Matthew Adams

Contractualism, Complaints, and Risk

Bastian Steuwer

The Contribution of Security to Well-being

Jonathan Herington

The Normative Significance of Conscience

Kyle Swan and Kevin Vallier

Portico